Helen Joyce

Helen Joyce

Genderism’s Groundhog Day

Appearing before the draft Conversion Practices Bill scrutiny committee

Helen Joyce's avatar
Helen Joyce
Nov 18, 2026
∙ Paid

I meant to post soon after giving evidence to the short-life select committee examining the government’s plans to criminalise so-called “conversion practices”, but I haven’t had a spare moment. At first the intensive preparation for the hearing meant everything else got postponed, and then once it was over I had to catch up on sidelined things and sprint to prepare submissions to the call for evidence on behalf of both Sex Matters and myself, and to support other individuals and organisations to submit as well. (Submissions become the property of the committee and can’t be published by their authors unless and until the committee gives permission; I’ll publish mine here as soon as am allowed to.)

If you missed the session and can cope with the “when did you stop beating your wife” tenor of the questions, you can watch back on the Parliament.tv archive. The first hour is the genderists, the second hour is Dennis Kavanagh of Gay Men’s Network, Dermot Kehoe of LGB Alliance, and me.

The main task for me and my two co-witnesses was to demolish the idea that the bill is a targeted measure that affects nobody but the poor victims of “the gap” — the supposed lacuna in current law that permits gay and trans-identifying people to be heinously abused with the intention of changing their sexuality or identity. In reality, there are plenty of laws that can be used to prosecute such abuse, including those banning assault, child cruelty and coercive control. If there is a gap, it is tiny, and no evidence has been provided that it is being exploited by conversion practitioners to abuse with impunity.

Instead what the bill does is criminalise a very wide range of currently lawful utterances, not just within families but also in schools, businesses, associations and friendship groups. During the oral hearing, Dennis, Dermot and I all emphasised, in different ways and with different examples, that the people who would suffer most because of the bill were parents. The thing I said that got picked up afterwards on social media was a worked example of this.

X avatar for @roseveniceallan
Venice Allan@roseveniceallan
“If my husband takes my phone away from me because he doesn’t want me contacting people, that’s coercive control. If I do that to my child, that maybe responsible parenting” Well said @HJoyceGender! #BinTheBill
3:57 PM · Oct 29, 2026 · 360K Views

128 Replies · 1.11K Reposts · 5.51K Likes

This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Helen Joyce.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Helen Joyce · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.